Experimental Composite Indicators of Cyclical Response in Surveys of Consumer Expectations of the Population

The article proposes a theoretical rationale and procedure for constructing new composite indicators that combine the results of quarterly consumer expectations surveys conducted by the Federal State Statistics Service (Rosstat). The information capabilities of surveys for the period 2005–2021 were studied to find the best alternative to the traditional consumer confidence index in the context of early estimates of the growth in household final consumption. The experimental Consumer Behavior Index reflects the «common profile» in the changes in the key parameters of consumer activity. The index is based on time series of primary survey indicators with high cross-correlation coefficients and a confirmed statistically significant causal relationship with a statistical referent – the growth rate of the final consumption expenditure of households. The new Consumer Anxiety Index with a counter-directional profile assesses the scale and tendencies of household response to market shocks based on short-term gaps between the indicator components and their long-term average.
In accordance with the proposed procedure for statistical testing of the time series, a cross-correlation analysis was carried out. Granger causality was studied, principal component analyses applied, unobservable cyclical components were identified in the dynamics of the Consumer Behavior Index and the referent using Hodrick – Prescott, Christian – Fitzgerald and Kalman statistical filters, and phase-by-phase movement of these components is demonstrated. A statistically significant cyclical correspondence and a close relationship of leading and coinciding nature between the composite survey-based index and the growth rate of the final consumption expenditure of households were confirmed.

1. Katona G. Psychological Analysis of Business Decisions and Expectation. American Economic Review. 1946;36(1):44–63.

2. Katona G. Psychological Analysis of Economic Behaviour. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1951.

3. Katona G. Rational Behavior and Economic Behavior. Psychological Review. 1953;60(5):307–318. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1037/h0060640.

4. Katona G. Repetitiousness and Variability of Consumer Behavior. Human Relations. 1959;12(1):35–49.

5. Katona G. Consumer Behavior: Theory and Findings on Expectations and Aspirations. American Economic Review. 1968;58(2):19–30.

6. Katona G. Consumer Durable Spending: Explanations and Prediction. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. 1971;(1):234–239.

7. UN. Handbook on Economic Tendency Surveys United Nations. New York: UN; 2015. 145 p.

8. Kitrar L.A., Lipkind T.M., Ostapkovich G.V. A New Business Climate Index in the Russian Manufacturing. Voprosy Statistiki. 2018;25(8):15–24. (In Russ.)

9. Kitrar L., Lipkind T. Analysis of the Relationship Between the Economic Sentiment Indicator and GDP Growth. Economic Policy. 2020;16(6):8–41. (In Russ.) Available from: https://doi.org/10.18288/1994-5124-2020-6-8-41.

10. Kitrar L.A., Lipkind T.M. Development of Composite Indicators of Cyclical Response in Business Surveys. Voprosy Statistiki. 2021;28(2):24–41. (In Russ.) Available from: https://doi.org/10.34023/2313-6383-2021-28-2-24-41.

11. Kitrar L.A., Lipkind T.M., Usov N.A. Forecasting GDP Growth Considering Crisis Shocks Based on Business Survey Results. Voprosy Statistiki. 2021;28(4):80–95. (In Russ.) Available from: https://doi.org/10.34023/2313-6383-2021-28-4-80-95.

12. Friedman M. A Theory of the Consumption Function. National Bureau of Economic Research. Princeton University Press; 1957. P. 20–37.

13. Campbell J.Y., Mankiw G. Consumption, Income, and Interest Rates: Reinterpreting the Time Series Evidence. NBER Macroeconomics Annual. 1989;4:185–245.

14. Blanchard O., Fischer S. Lectures on Macroeconomics. Cambridge: MIT Press; 1989. 664 p.

15. Juster F.Th., Wachtel P. Anticipatory and Objective Models of Durable Goods Demand. Explorations in Economic Research. 1974;1(2):136–188.

16. Mishkin F.S. Consumer Sentiment and Spending on Durable Goods. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. 1978;1:217–232.

17. Throop A.W. Consumer Sentiment: Its Causes and Effects. Federal Reserve of San Francisco Review. 1992;1:35–39.

18. Fuhrer J.C. What Role Does Consumer Sentiment Play in the U.S. Macroeconomy? New England Economic Review. 1993;1:32–44.

19. Carroll C.D., Fuhrer J.C., Wilcox D.W. Does Consumer Sentiment Forecast Household Spending? If So, Why? American Economic Review. 1994;84(5):1397–1408.

20. Bram J., Ludvigson S.C. Does Consumer Confidence Forecast Household Expenditure? A Sentiment Index Horse Race. Economic Policy Review. 1998;4(2):59–78.

21. Lovell M.C. Why Was the Consumer Feeling So Sad? Brooking Papers on Economic Activity. 1975;2:473–479.

22. Granger С.W.J. Investigating Casual Relations by Econometric Methods and Cross-Spectral Methods. Econometrica. 1969;37(3):424–438. Available from: https://doi.org/10.2307/1912791.

23. Howrey E.Ph. The Predictive Power of the Index of Consumer Sentiment. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. 2001;(1):175–216.

24. Garner C.A. Consumer Confidence After September 11. Economic Review – Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. 2002;87(Q II):1–21.

25. Nardo M. The Quantification of Qualitative Survey Data: A Critical Assessment. Journal of Economic Surveys. 2003;17(5):645–668.

26. Desroches B., Gosselin M.A. Evaluating Threshold Effects in Consumer Sentiment. Southern Economic Journal. 2004;70(4):942–952.

27. Ludvigson S.C. Consumer Confidence and Consumer Spending. Journal of Economic Perspectives. 2004;18(2):29–50.

28. Croushore D. Do Consumer-Confidence Indexes Help Forecast Consumer Spending in Real Time? The North American Journal of Economics and Finance. 2005;16(3):435–450. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.najef.2005.05.002.

29. Keyfitz R. US Consumers and the War in Iraq: The Non-Economics of Consumer Confidence. Business Economics. 2004;39(2):28–23.

30. Curtin R.T. Current Research and Development Agenda for the U. S. Consumer Surveys. OECD Workshop, Brussels, Belgium, November 21, 2003.

31. Curtin R.T. Consumer Sentiment Surveys: Worldwide Review and Assessment. Journal of Business Cycle Measurement and Analysis. 2007;3(1):7–42. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1787/jbcma-v2007-art2-en.

32. Curtin R.T. A Consumer Expectations: Micro Foundations and Macro Impact. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2019. 360 p. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1017/9780511791598.

33. Dees S., Soares B.P. Consumer Confidence as a Predictor of Consumption Spending: Evidence for the United States and the Euro Area. International Economics. 2013;134:1–14.

34. Lahiri K., Zhao Y. Determinants of Consumer Sentiment Over Business Cycles: Evidence from the US Surveys of Consumers. Journal of Business Cycle Research. 2016;12(2):187–215. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41549-016-0010-5.

35. Malgarini M., Margani P. Psychology, Consumer Sentiment and Household Expenditures. Applied Economics. 2007;39(13):1719–1729.

36. Campelo A.Jr., Bittencourt V.S., Malgarini M. Consumers Confidence and Households Consumption in Brazil: Evidence from the FGV Survey. Journal of Business Cycle Research. 2020;16(1):19–34. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41549-020-00042-2.

37. Ramalho E.A., Caleiro A., Dionfsio A. Explaining Consumer Confidence in Portugal. Journal of Economic Psychology. 2011;32(1):25–32.

38. Jonsson A., Lindén S. The Quest for the Best Consumer Confidence Indicator. European Economy – Economic Papers 372. Brussels: European Commission; 2009. Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/publications/pages/publication14353_en.pdf.

39. Acemoglu D., Scott A. Consumer Confidence and Rational Expectations: Are Agents’ Beliefs Consistent with the Theory? The Economic Journal. 1994;104(422):1–19. Available from: https://doi.org/10.2307/2234671.

40. Stock J., Watson M.W. Business Cycle Fluctuations in US Macroeconomic Time Series. In: Taylor J.B., Woodford M. (eds). Handbook of Macroeconomics. Vol. 1. Part A. North Holland; 1999. P. 3–64.

41. Gayer C., Genet J. Using Factor Models to Construct Composite Indicators from BCS Data – A Comparison with European Commission Confidence Indicators. Economic Papers No. 240. Brussels: European Commission; 2006. 50 p.

42. Arkhipova M.Yu., Sirotin V.P., Sukhareva N.A. Development of a Composite Indicator for Measuring the Value and Dynamics of Digital Inequality in Russia. Voprosy Statistiki. 2018;25(4):75–87. (In Russ.)

43. Stone M., Brooks R.J. Continuum Regression: Cross‐Validated Sequentially Constructed Prediction Embracing Ordinary Least Squares, Partial Least Squares and Principal Components Regression. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B (Methodological). 1990;52(2):237–258.

44. Helland I.S. Some Theoretical Aspects of Partial Least Squares Regression. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems. 2001;58(2):97–107.

45. Gelper S., Croux C. On the Construction of the European Economic Sentiment Indicator. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics. 2010;72(1):47–62. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0084.2009.00574.x.

46. Nilsson R., Gyomai G. Cycle Extraction: A Comparison of the Phase-Average Trend Method, the Hodrick – Prescott and Christiano – Fitzgerald Filters. OECD Statistics Directorate Working Paper No. 39. 2011. Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/db_indicators/surveys/documents/workshops/2008/ec_meeting/nilsson_gyomai_oecd.pdf.

47. Christiano L.J., Fitzgerald T.J. The Band Pass Filter. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 7257. Cambridge, MA; 1999. Available from: https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w7257/w7257.pdf.

48. Harvey D. From Managerialism to Entrepreneurialism: The Transformation in Urban Governance in Late Capitalism. Geografiska Annaler. Series B, Human Geography. 1989;71(1):3–17.

49. Koopman S.J., Durbin J. Fast Filtering and Smoothing for Multivariate State Space Models. Journal of Time Series Analysis. 2000;21(3):281–296.

50. Kitrar L.A., Lipkind T.M., Ostapkovich G.V. Decomposition and Joined Analysis of Growth Cycles in the Dynamics of Economic Sentiment Indicator and Volume Index of the Gross Domestic Product. Voprosy Statistiki. 2014;(9):41–46. (In Russ.)